The Mac-Native Alternative to Carbonite
Carbonite was built for Windows. Capsule Backup was built for Mac — using Time Machine, the way Apple intended backups to work.
| Feature |
Capsule Backup
|
Carbonite
|
|---|---|---|
| Full Time Machine backup | ||
| Complete OS restore via Migration Assistant | ||
| No software to install | ||
| Native macOS integration | ||
| Unlimited devices per plan | ||
| External drive backup | Plus plan & above | |
| Backup versioning | Unlimited (Time Machine) | 1 year |
| Upload speed | 1 Gbps, no throttling | Throttled |
| Data region choice | Germany, Finland, USA | USA only |
| VPN included | ||
| IP whitelisting | ||
| Starting price | $8/mo for 1 TB | ~$6/mo (1 PC only) |
Why Mac Users Choose Capsule Over Carbonite
Native Time Machine, Zero Software
Carbonite requires installing a proprietary backup client that runs in the background, consuming system resources. Capsule Backup uses macOS Time Machine directly over SMB3 — no agent, no extra software, no compatibility issues. Your Mac already knows how to back up; Capsule just gives it a cloud destination.
Full Mac Restore, Not Just Files
Carbonite backs up individual files, but it cannot restore your entire macOS system. With Capsule Backup, use Migration Assistant to restore everything — your OS, apps, settings, user accounts, and files — to any Mac, exactly as it was. It's a true disaster recovery solution.
Unlimited Devices, No Per-PC Pricing
Carbonite licenses are per-computer — every Mac needs its own subscription. Capsule Backup plans include unlimited devices. Back up your MacBook, iMac, and Mac Mini all on a single plan. Add a new Mac? Just connect it. No extra cost.
Backup Approach: Proprietary vs. Native
Carbonite uses a proprietary backup agent that must be downloaded, installed, and kept updated. On Mac, its feature set is more limited than on Windows — features like Mirror Image (bare-metal restore) are Windows-only. The Mac client backs up user files but does not integrate with Time Machine or macOS recovery tools.
Capsule Backup takes the opposite approach. It provides a cloud-based SMB3 share that Time Machine connects to natively. There is no client to install. Backups are managed by macOS itself, using the same Time Machine interface you already know. This means you get automatic, hourly, versioned backups — and full system restore via Migration Assistant.
Performance: Speed Without Throttling
One of the most common complaints about Carbonite is upload speed throttling. Initial backups can take days or even weeks, and Carbonite has been known to reduce upload speeds after a certain amount of data is transferred. There is no way to adjust bandwidth allocation.
Capsule Backup connects to 1 Gbps fiber infrastructure with no bandwidth limits or throttling. Your backup speed is limited only by your own internet connection. Large initial backups complete much faster, and incremental Time Machine backups are typically finished in minutes.
Security & Data Sovereignty
Carbonite encrypts data in transit and at rest using 128-bit Blowfish encryption on its servers, all hosted in the United States. There is no option to choose a different data region, which may raise compliance concerns for users subject to GDPR or other regional data protection regulations.
Capsule Backup uses SMB3 encrypted transport combined with Time Machine's own AES-XTS encryption. You can choose your data region — Germany, Finland, or the USA — to meet regulatory requirements. Additional security features include IP whitelisting and an included WireGuard VPN for secure access from any network. Your 99.9% SLA ensures availability when you need it.
Pricing: Transparent and Device-Inclusive
Carbonite's personal plans start around $6/month (Basic), $9/month (Plus), and $12.50/month (Premium). However, each plan covers only a single computer. To back up three Macs, you need three subscriptions. The Basic plan also excludes external drive backup, and the Mac version lacks the full-system Mirror Image feature available on Windows.
Capsule Backup starts at $8/month for 1 TB with unlimited devices. The 5 TB plan ($35/month) and 10 TB plan ($65/month) scale for larger needs — still with unlimited devices. Every plan includes VPN, IP whitelisting, and a 7-day free trial with no credit card required.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Carbonite support Time Machine on Mac?
No. Carbonite uses its own proprietary backup client on Mac. It does not integrate with Time Machine, which means you cannot use Migration Assistant for full system restores. Capsule Backup works directly with Time Machine over SMB3, giving you native macOS backup and restore capabilities.
Can I restore my entire Mac from a Carbonite backup?
Not on Mac. Carbonite's Mirror Image feature (bare-metal restore) is available only on Windows. On macOS, Carbonite can restore individual files, but you would need to manually reinstall macOS, your applications, and your settings. With Capsule Backup, Migration Assistant restores your entire system — OS, apps, settings, and files — in one step.
Is Carbonite slower than Capsule Backup?
Carbonite is known for throttling upload speeds, especially during large initial backups. Many users report initial backups taking days or weeks. Capsule Backup connects to 1 Gbps fiber infrastructure with no throttling or bandwidth caps, so your backup speed is limited only by your own internet connection.
Can I back up multiple Macs with one Carbonite subscription?
No. Each Carbonite personal plan covers a single computer. If you have multiple Macs, you need a separate subscription for each one. Capsule Backup includes unlimited devices on every plan — back up all your Macs with a single subscription starting at $8/month.
Can I choose where my data is stored with Carbonite?
No. Carbonite stores all data in the United States with no option to select a different region. Capsule Backup lets you choose between data centers in Germany, Finland, or the USA, making it easier to comply with GDPR and other data residency requirements.
Explore More
Capsule Backup is not affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc. Time Machine, macOS, Finder, and Migration Assistant are trademarks of Apple Inc.